A quiz

Where do you stand?

Twelve statements about the mind. Say whether you agree, and see how close you are to Daniel Dennett, which thinkers on this site are nearest to you, and exactly where you part company with him.

A young knight in armour sleeps beneath a slender tree. On the left a woman in a plain dark dress offers him a sword and a book; on the right a woman in brighter clothes holds out a sprig of flowers. Behind them a rocky castle and blue hills.
Raphael, Vision of a Knight, c. 1504. A sleeping knight between two choices, usually read as duty and pleasure, or the active and the contemplative life. He has to pick a side. So do you, though here "not sure" is allowed.National Gallery, London. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

There are no right answers here, only answers that commit you to things. Dennett's answers are the illusionist's: no zombies, no new fact for Mary, no ineffable qualia, and no hard problem left over once the easy ones are solved. The comparisons with other thinkers are our reading of their views, and some of them never addressed some of these questions; where they did not, we leave them out of the match.

    About the statements

    Each statement is a famous fork in the road. The zombie is Chalmers's, Mary is Frank Jackson's, the Chinese room is John Searle's. The neuron-by-neuron replacement is Chalmers's fading qualia argument, whose conclusion Dennett happily accepts. The question about being wrong about your own experience is the heart of illusionism, and the one about the self runs from Hume's bundle to Metzinger's self-model. For the machine questions, see Could a machine be conscious?

    Your position on the line is simply how often you agree with Dennett, so the far end means disagreeing with him on almost everything. Your nearest thinkers are found by comparing your answers with theirs on the statements they took a view on.